Retro Hugo Award
Presented by: Members of Worldcon
For: Best science fiction and fantasy works (retrospective)
| Winner | Shadow Over Mars | Leigh Brackett |
| Runner-up | Sirius: A Fantasy of Love and Discord | Olaf Stapledon |
| Finalist | The Winged Man | E. Mayne Hull+A. E. van Vogt |
| Finalist | The Golden Fleece | Robert Graves |
| Finalist | Land of Terror | Edgar Rice Burroughs |
| Nominee | The Wind on the Moon | Eric Linklater |
| Nominee | Renaissance | Raymond F. Jones |
| Nominee | Time Must Have a Stop | Aldous Huxley |
| Nominee | That Hideous Strength | C. S. Lewis |
| Nominee | The Delicate Ape | Dorothy B. Hughes |
| Nominee | Worlds Beginning | Robert Ardrey |
| Nominee | Le voyageur imprudent | René Barjavel |
| Nominee | Magic Moon | Edmond Hamilton |
| Nominee | Miss Shumway Waves a Wand | James Hadley Chase |
| Nominee | Destiny Times Three | Fritz Leiber |
| Nominee | Animal Farm | George Orwell |
| Nominee | The World of Null-A | A. E. van Vogt |
| Nominee | The Golden Amazon | John Russell Fearn |
| Winner | Killdozer! | Theodore Sturgeon |
| Runner-up | The Jewel of Bas | Leigh Brackett |
| Finalist | The Changeling | A. E. van Vogt |
| Finalist | Trog | Murray Leinster |
| Finalist | A God Named Kroo | Henry Kuttner |
| Nominee | Intruders from the Stars | Ross Rocklynne |
| Nominee | Old Man in New World | Olaf Stapledon |
| Nominee | Wanderers of the Wolf Moon | Nelson S. Bond |
| Nominee | Strangers on the Heights | Manly Wade Wellman |
| Nominee | Judgment Night | C. L. Moore |
| Nominee | Plague | Murray Leinster |
| Nominee | The Mad Robot | William P. McGivern |
| Nominee | The Giant Runt | Ross Rocklynne |
| Nominee | Star Base X | Robert Moore Williams |
| Nominee | The Dweller in Darkness | August Derleth |
| Nominee | The Return of Jongor | Robert Moore Williams |
| Nominee | Giant Killer | A. Bertram Chandler |
| Nominee | Dead Hand | Isaac Asimov |
| Nominee | The Mule | Isaac Asimov |
| Nominee | Sword of Tomorrow | Henry Kuttner |
| Nominee | Murder in Space | David V. Reed |
| Nominee | Minions of the Crystal Sphere | Albert dePina |
| Winner | City | Clifford D. Simak |
| Runner-up | No Woman Born | C. L. Moore |
| Finalist | Arena | Fredric Brown |
| Finalist | When the Bough Breaks | Lewis Padgett |
| Finalist | The Big and the Little | Isaac Asimov |
| Finalist | The Children's Hour | Lawrence O'Donnell |
| Nominee | The Veil of Astellar | Leigh Brackett |
| Nominee | Deadline | Cleve Cartmill |
| Nominee | Terror Out of Space | Leigh Brackett |
| Nominee | Census | Clifford D. Simak |
| Nominee | Ride the El to Doom | Allison V. Harding |
| Nominee | The Day the World Stood Still | Allison V. Harding |
| Nominee | Technical Error | Hal Clement |
| Nominee | The Dweller in Darkness | August Derleth |
| Nominee | Plague | Murray Leinster |
| Nominee | The Beasts of Barsac | Robert Bloch |
| Winner | I, Rocket | Ray Bradbury |
| Runner-up | Desertion | Clifford D. Simak |
| Finalist | Huddling Place | Clifford D. Simak |
| Finalist | The Wedge | Isaac Asimov |
| Finalist | And the Gods Laughed | Fredric Brown |
| Nominee | Far Centaurus | A. E. van Vogt |
| Nominee | The Lake | Ray Bradbury |
| Nominee | Catch That Rabbit | Isaac Asimov |
| Nominee | Kindness | Lester del Rey |
| Nominee | Housing Problem | Henry Kuttner+C. L. Moore |
| Nominee | The Yehudi Principle | Fredric Brown |
| Nominee | Sanity | Fritz Leiber |
| Nominee | And Then—the Silence | Ray Bradbury |
| Nominee | Hoofs | Manly Wade Wellman |
| Nominee | Invariant | John R. Pierce |
| Nominee | The Gothic Window | Dorothy Quick |
| Winner | The Cthulhu Mythos | H. P. Lovecraft+August Derleth+others |
| Runner-up | Pellucidar | Edgar Rice Burroughs |
| Finalist | Doc Savage | Kenneth Robeson |
| Finalist | The Shadow | Maxwell Grant |
| Finalist | Captain Future | Brett Sterling |
| Nominee | Jules de Grandin | Seabury Quinn |
| Nominee | Foundation | Isaac Asimov |
| Nominee | Venus Equilateral | George O. Smith |
| Nominee | City | Clifford D. Simak |
| Nominee | Buck Rogers | Dick Calkins |
| Nominee | Flash Gordon | Alex Raymond |
| Nominee | Golden Amazon | John Russell Fearn |
| Nominee | John Thunstone | Manly Wade Wellman |
| Nominee | Robots | Isaac Asimov |
| Nominee | Jorkens | Lord Dunsany |
| Nominee | G-8 & His Battle Aces | Robert J. Hogan |
| Winner | The Science-Fiction Field | Leigh Brackett |
| Runner-up | Fancyclopedia | Jack Speer |
| Finalist | The Works of H. P. Lovecraft: Suggestions for a Critical Appraisal | Fritz Leiber |
| Finalist | Rockets: The Future of Travel Beyond the Stratosphere | Willy Ley |
| Finalist | Mr. Tompkins Explores the Atom | George Gamow |
| Nominee | '42 to '44: A Contemporary Memoir Upon Human Behaviour During the Crisis of the World Revolution | H. G. Wells |
| Nominee | The Book of Thoth | Aleister Crowley |
| Nominee | Marginalia | H. P. Lovecraft |
| Nominee | Little Known Fantaisistes | Harold Wakefield |
| Nominee | Futurian War Digest - 1944 | J. Michael Rosenblum |
| Nominee | The Story Behind the Story: Veil of Astellar | Leigh Brackett |
| Nominee | The Grey Mouser | Fritz Leiber |
| Nominee | A Treasury of American Folklore | B. A. Botkin |
| Nominee | The Inner Ring | C. S. Lewis |
| Nominee | Panic: The Orson Welles Broadcast That Hoaxed America | Orson Welles |
| Nominee | Rockets: A Prelude to Space Travel | Willy Ley |
| Winner | Superman: "The Mysterious Mr. Mxyztplk" | Jerry Siegel+Joe Shuster+Ira Yarbrough |
| Runner-up | Donald Duck: "The Mad Chemist" | Carl Barks |
| Finalist | The Spirit: "For the Love of Clara Defoe" | Manly Wade Wellman+Lou Fine+Don Komisarow |
| Finalist | Buck Rogers: "Hollow Planetoid" | Dick Calkins |
| Finalist | Flash Gordon: "Battle for Tropica" | Alex Raymond |
| Nominee | Flash Gordon: "Triumph in Tropica" | Alex Raymond |
| Nominee | Plastic Man: The Gay Nineties Nightmare | |
| Nominee | Detective Comics #94 Batman | |
| Nominee | Buck Rogers: Planet of the Rising Sun | |
| Nominee | Captain Marvel Adventures: Silvana's Twin | |
| Nominee | Captain Marvel Adventures: Monster Society of Evil | |
| Nominee | Lady Satan: The Allied Assassination Plot | |
| Nominee | Ibis The Invincible: Loki The Terrible | |
| Nominee | Buck Rogers: Monkeymen of Planet X | |
| Nominee | Buck Rogers: Plastic Percy | |
| Nominee | Red Rackham's Treasure | |
| Nominee | Mandrake: The Earthshaker | |
| Nominee | Brick Bradford: Beyond the Crystal Door | |
| Nominee | Mandrake: The Mirror People | |
| Nominee | Mandrake: The Garden of Wuzzu | |
| Nominee | The Phantom: High-Sea Hijacker | |
| Nominee | Mandrake the Magician: The Dome |
| Nominee | The Uninvited | |
| Nominee | The Canterville Ghost | |
| Nominee | Captain America | |
| Nominee | Between Two Worlds | |
| Nominee | It Happened Tomorrow | |
| Nominee | The Curse of the Cat People | |
| Nominee | The Lady and The Monster | |
| Nominee | The Invisible Man's Revenge |
| Winner | The Canterville Ghost | Edwin Harvey Blum+Oscar Wilde+Jules Dassin |
| Winner | The Curse of the Cat People | DeWitt Bodeen+Gunther V. Fritsch+Robert Wise (1914-2005) |
| Finalist | Donovan's Brain | Robert L. Richards (adaptor)+Curt Siodmak+William Spier |
| Finalist | It Happened Tomorrow | Dudley Nichols+René Clair |
| Finalist | House of Frankenstein | Edward T. Lowe, Jr.+Curt Siodmak+Erle C. Kenton |
| Nominee | The Invisible Man's Revenge | Bertram Millhauser+Ford Beebe |
| Nominee | Beware of Tomorrow | |
| Nominee | The Uninvited | |
| Nominee | The Lady and the Monster | |
| Nominee | And to Think That I Saw It on Mulberry Street | |
| Nominee | Ali Baba & the Forty Thieves | |
| Nominee | They Came to a City | |
| Nominee | The Old Gray Hare | |
| Nominee | The Queen of the Cats | |
| Nominee | Time Flies | |
| Nominee | Man who Dreamed Too Much |
| Winner | untitled | John W. Campbell, Jr. |
| Runner-up | untitled | Dorothy McIlwraith |
| Finalist | untitled | Mary Gnaedinger |
| Finalist | untitled | Raymond A. Palmer |
| Finalist | untitled | Oscar J. Friend |
| Nominee | untitled | W. Scott Peacock |
| Nominee | untitled | Babette Rosmond |
| Nominee | untitled | Donald A. Wollheim |
| Nominee | untitled | Bernard G. Davis |
| Nominee | untitled | Frederik Pohl |
| Nominee | untitled | Sam Moskowitz |
| Nominee | untitled | William de Grouchy |
| Nominee | untitled | John W. Campbell, Jr. |
| Nominee | untitled | Donald A. Wollheim |
| Nominee | untitled | Roger Senhouse |
| Winner | untitled | Margaret Brundage |
| Runner-up | untitled | Earle Bergey |
| Finalist | untitled | Boris Dolgov |
| Finalist | untitled | Paul Orban |
| Finalist | untitled | William Timmins |
| Nominee | untitled | Matt Fox |
| Nominee | untitled | Lawrence Stevens |
| Nominee | untitled | Chesley Bonestell |
| Nominee | untitled | Virgil Finlay |
| Nominee | untitled | Harry Lemon Parkhurst |
| Nominee | untitled | Graham Ingels |
| Nominee | untitled | Vin Sullivan |
| Nominee | untitled | Hannes Bok |
| Nominee | untitled | A. R. Tilburne |
| Nominee | untitled | Rudolph Belarski |
| Nominee | untitled | J. Allen St. John |
| Nominee | untitled | Modest Stein |
| Nominee | untitled | Frank R. Paul |
| Nominee | Radio Society of Great Britain |
| Winner | Voice of the Imagi-Nation - 1944 | Forrest J. Ackerman+Morojo |
| Runner-up | Le Zombie - 1944 | E. E. Evans+Bob Tucker |
| Finalist | Futurian War Digest - 1944 | J. Michael Rosenblum |
| Finalist | The Acolyte - 1944 | Francis T. Laney+Samuel D. Russell |
| Finalist | Shangri L'Affaires - 1944 | Charles Burbee |
| Nominee | Diablerie - 1944 | Bill Watson |
| Nominee | Fantasy Times - 1944 | Sam Moskowitz |
| Nominee | Chanticleer | Walt Liebscher |
| Nominee | Centauri - 1944 | Andy Anderson |
| Nominee | The Phantagraph - 1944 | Donald A. Wollheim |
| Nominee | Fanewscard Weekly - 1944 | Connor+Robinson |
| Nominee | Sappho - 1944 | Ebey+Watson |
| Nominee | Toward Tomorrow - 1944 | James Kepner |
| Nominee | British Fantasy Society Bulletin - 1944 | D. R. Smith |
| Nominee | Horizons - 1944 | Harry Warner, Jr. |
| Nominee | Fantasticonglomeration - 1944 | The Ackermaniac |
| Nominee | Zizzle-Pop - 1944 | Louis Russell Chauvenet |
| Nominee | The Fantasite - 1944 | Philip R. Bronson |
| Nominee | Guteto - 1944 | Morojo |
| Nominee | Fantasy Fiction Field - 1944 | Julius Unger |
| Nominee | YHOS - 1944 | Pvt. Art Widner, Jr. |
| Winner | untitled | Fritz Leiber |
| Runner-up | untitled | Bob Tucker |
| Finalist | untitled | Morojo |
| Finalist | untitled | Jack Speer |
| Finalist | untitled | Harry Warner, Jr. |
| Nominee | untitled | J. Michael Rosenblum |
| Nominee | untitled | David Langford |
| Nominee | untitled | Russell Chauvenet |
| Nominee | untitled | Sam Moskowitz |
| Nominee | untitled | Francis T. Laney |
| Nominee | untitled | Charles Burbee |
| Nominee | untitled | T. Bruce Yerke |
| Nominee | untitled | Julius Unger |
| Nominee | untitled | Ted Carnell |
| Nominee | untitled | Donald A. Wollheim |
| Nominee | untitled | Art Widner |
| Nominee | untitled | E. Everett Evans |
| Nominee | untitled | Bill Watson |
| Nominee | untitled | Harold Wakefield |
| Nominee | untitled | Samuel D. Russell |
| Nominee | untitled | Robert Bloch |
| Nominee | untitled | Milton A. Rothman |
| Nominee | untitled | Elmer Perdue |
| Nominee | untitled | Forrest J. Ackerman |
| Nominee | untitled | Elsie Wollheim |
| Nominee | untitled | Alva Rogers |
| Nominee | untitled | Bill Watson |
| Winner | Conjure Wife (Complete Novel) | Fritz Leiber, Jr. |
| Runner-up | Gather, Darkness! | Fritz Leiber |
| Finalist | The Weapon Makers | A. E. van Vogt |
| Finalist | Perelandra | C. S. Lewis |
| Finalist | Earth's Last Citadel | Henry Kuttner+C. L. Moore |
| Nominee | Das Glasperlenspiel | Hermann Hesse |
| Nominee | Judgment Night | C. L. Moore |
| Nominee | The Case of Charles Dexter Ward | H. P. Lovecraft |
| Nominee | The Book of Ptath | A. E. van Vogt |
| Nominee | Mary Poppins Opens the Door | P. L. Travers |
| Nominee | The Magic Faraway Tree | Enid Blyton |
| Nominee | Ravage | René Barjavel |
| Nominee | Sirius: A Fantasy of Love and Discord | Olaf Stapledon |
| Nominee | Malpertuis | Jean Ray |
| Nominee | Fog Magic | Julia L. Sauer |
| Nominee | The Black, Black Witch | Kenneth Robeson |
| Winner | The Little Prince | Antoine de Saint-Exupéry |
| Runner-up | The Magic Bed-Knob; or, How to Become a Witch in Ten Easy Lessons | Mary Norton |
| Finalist | The Dream-Quest of Unknown Kadath | H. P. Lovecraft |
| Finalist | Attitude | Hal Clement |
| Finalist | We Print the Truth | Anthony Boucher |
| Nominee | Clash by Night | Lawrence O'Donnell |
| Nominee | Opposites—React! | Jack Williamson |
| Nominee | One-Way Trip | Anthony Boucher |
| Nominee | The Great Brain Panic | Don Wilcox |
| Nominee | Wet Magic | Henry Kuttner |
| Nominee | Wings of Icarus | Ray Cummings |
| Nominee | Exile to Centauri | Ross Rocklynne |
| Nominee | The Lost Warship | Robert Moore Williams |
| Nominee | Killdozer! | Theodore Sturgeon |
| Nominee | Genie of Bagdad | William P. McGivern |
| Nominee | The Robot Master | Walter B. Gibson |
| Nominee | Hell Hath Fury | Cleve Cartmill |
| Nominee | The Giant Atom | Malcolm Jameson |
| Nominee | The Unpleasant Profession of Jonathan Hoag | Robert A. Heinlein |
| Nominee | Waldo | Robert A. Heinlein |
| Winner | Mimsy Were the Borogoves | Lewis Padgett |
| Runner-up | Thieves' House | Fritz Leiber, Jr. |
| Finalist | Citadel of Lost Ships | Leigh Brackett |
| Finalist | The Halfling | Leigh Brackett |
| Finalist | The Proud Robot | Lewis Padgett |
| Nominee | Symbiotica | Eric Frank Russell |
| Nominee | Daymare | Fredric Brown |
| Nominee | The Cave | P. Schuyler Miller |
| Nominee | The Storm | A. E. van Vogt |
| Nominee | Message From Mars | Clifford D. Simak |
| Nominee | The Angelic Angleworm | Fredric Brown |
| Nominee | Elsewhen | Anthony Boucher |
| Nominee | Time Locker | Henry Kuttner |
| Nominee | The Beast | A. E. van Vogt |
| Nominee | Thralls of the Endless Night | Leigh Brackett |
| Nominee | Greenface | James H. Schmitz |
| Winner | King of the Gray Spaces | Ray Bradbury |
| Runner-up | Death Sentence | Isaac Asimov |
| Finalist | Doorway Into Time | C. L. Moore |
| Finalist | Yours Truly, Jack the Ripper | Robert Bloch |
| Finalist | Exile | Edmond Hamilton |
| Nominee | Q. U. R. | H. H. Holmes |
| Nominee | The Gremlins | Roald Dahl |
| Nominee | The Iron Standard | Lewis Padgett |
| Nominee | Nothing But Gingerbread Left | Henry Kuttner+C. L. Moore |
| Nominee | The Geezenstacks | Fredric Brown |
| Nominee | The Scythe | Ray Bradbury |
| Nominee | El milagro secreto | Jorge Luis Borges |
| Nominee | They Bite | Anthony Boucher |
| Nominee | The Crowd | Ray Bradbury |
| Nominee | The Wind | Ray Bradbury |
| Nominee | The Devil Is Not Mocked | Manly Wade Wellman |
| Nominee | Barsoom (Mars) | Edgar Rice Burroughs |
| Nominee | Doc Savage | Kenneth Robeson |
| Nominee | Captain Future | Edmond Hamilton |
| Nominee | The Shadow | Maxwell Grant |
| Nominee | Mary Poppins | P. L. Travers |
| Nominee | Fafhrd and the Grey Mouser | Fritz Leiber |
| Nominee | Cosmic Trilogy | C. S. Lewis |
| Winner | Wonder Woman #5: Battle for Womanhood | William Moulton Marsden+Harry G. Peter |
| Runner-up | Le Secret de la Licorne | Hergé |
| Finalist | Flash Gordon: Fiery Desert of Mongo | Alex Raymond |
| Finalist | Buck Rogers: Martians Invade Jupiter | Philip Nowlan+Dick Calkins |
| Finalist | Plastic Man #1: The Game of Death | Jack Cole |
| Nominee | Garth | Steve Dowling |
| Nominee | Nelvana of the Northern Lights and the Ice-Beam | |
| Nominee | Le Rayon U | |
| Nominee | Le Petit Prince | Antoine de Saint-Exupéry |
| Nominee | Tintin: Red Rackham's Treasure | |
| Nominee | Donald Duck: The Mummy's Ring | |
| Nominee | Donald Duck: The Victory Garden | |
| Nominee | The Man Who Wanted the World | |
| Nominee | Many Moons | |
| Nominee | All-Star Comics #18 | |
| Nominee | Otomox | |
| Nominee | Green Lantern #7 | |
| Nominee | The Crab with the Golden Claws | |
| Nominee | Buck Rogers: Mechanical Bloodhound | |
| Nominee | The Phantom: The Phantom's Engagement | |
| Nominee | Mandrake the Magician: Baron Kord | |
| Nominee | Brick Bradford: On the Throne of Titania | |
| Nominee | Submariner and The Green Island Menace | |
| Nominee | Captain America Comics |
| Winner | Heaven Can Wait | Samson Raphaelson+Ernst Lubitsch |
| Runner-up | Phantom of the Opera | Eric Taylor (screenwriter)+Samuel Hoffenstein+Hans Jacoby+Arthur Lubin |
| Finalist | Münchhausen | Erich Kästner+Rudolph Erich Raspe+Josef von Báky |
| Finalist | Batman | Victor McLeod+Leslie Swabacker+Harry L. Fraser+Lambert Hillyer |
| Finalist | Cabin in the Sky | Joseph Schrank+Vincente Minnelli+Busby Berkeley |
| Nominee | A Guy Named Joe | Frederick Hazlitt Brennan+Dalton Trumbo+Victor Fleming |
| Nominee | The Phantom | |
| Nominee | The Tin Men | |
| Nominee | The Curse of the Cat People | |
| Nominee | The Leopard Man | |
| Nominee | Faustus Kelly | Flann O'Brien |
| Nominee | Flesh and Fantasy | |
| Nominee | The Masked Marvel | |
| Nominee | Shadow of a Doubt | |
| Nominee | The Insect Play (Rhapsody in Stephen's Green) | Flann O'Brien |
| Nominee | Calling Dr. Death | |
| Nominee | Sherlock Holmes Faces Death |
| Winner | Frankenstein Meets the Wolfman | Curt Siodmak+Roy William Neill |
| Runner-up | I Walked With a Zombie | Curt Siodmak+Ardel Wray+Jacques Tourneur |
| Finalist | Super-Rabbit | Tedd Pierce+Chuck Jones |
| Finalist | The Seventh Victim | Charles O'Neal+DeWitt Bodeen+Mark Robson (director) |
| Finalist | Der Fuehrer's Face | Joe Grant+Dick Huemer+Jack Kinney |
| Nominee | The Ape Man | Barney A. Sarecky+William Beaudine |
| Nominee | The Underground World | |
| Nominee | Son of Dracula | |
| Nominee | Red Hot Riding Hood | |
| Nominee | La main du diable/Carnival of Sinners | |
| Nominee | Return of the Vampire | |
| Nominee | The Mad Ghoul | |
| Nominee | Meshes of the Afternoon | |
| Nominee | Captive Wild Woman | |
| Nominee | Momotaro's Sea Eagles | |
| Nominee | The Silent Village |
| Winner | untitled | John W. Campbell |
| Runner-up | untitled | Donald A. Wollheim |
| Finalist | untitled | Dorothy McIlwraith |
| Finalist | untitled | Mary Gnaedinger |
| Finalist | untitled | Raymond A. Palmer |
| Nominee | untitled | Oscar J. Friend |
| Nominee | untitled | Frederik Pohl |
| Nominee | untitled | Alden H. Norton |
| Nominee | untitled | Farnsworth Wright |
| Nominee | untitled | W. Scott Peacock |
| Nominee | untitled | Robert A. W. Lowndes |
| Nominee | untitled | Malcolm Reiss |
| Nominee | untitled | Frank A. Munsey |
| Nominee | untitled | John W. Campbell, Jr. |
| Winner | untitled | Virgil Finlay |
| Runner-up | untitled | Margaret Brundage |
| Finalist | untitled | Antoine de Saint-Exupéry |
| Finalist | untitled | Hannes Bok |
| Finalist | untitled | J. Allen St. John |
| Nominee | untitled | William Timmins |
| Nominee | untitled | Earle Bergey |
| Nominee | untitled | Edd Cartier |
| Nominee | untitled | Mervyn Peake |
| Nominee | untitled | George Rozen |
| Nominee | untitled | Frank R. Paul |
| Nominee | untitled | Dorothy M. Wheeler |
| Nominee | untitled | Harold W. McCauley |
| Nominee | untitled | Paul Orban |
| Nominee | untitled | Alex Schomburg |
| Nominee | untitled | A. R. Tilburne |
| Winner | Le Zombie - 1943 | E. E. Evans+Bob Tucker |
| Runner-up | The Phantagraph - 1943 | Donald A. Wollheim |
| Finalist | Futurian War Digest - 1943 | J. Michael Rosenblum |
| Finalist | Voice of the Imagi-Nation - 1943 | Jack Erman+Morojo |
| Finalist | YHOS - 1943 | Art Widner |
| Nominee | Guteto - 1943 | Morojo |
| Nominee | Fantasy-News - 1943 | William S. Sykora |
| Nominee | Sustaining Program - 1943 | Jack F. Speer |
| Nominee | Nebula - 1943 | Larry T. Shaw |
| Nominee | Fantasy Fiction Field - 1943 | Julius Unger |
| Nominee | Shangri L'Affaires - 1943 | Alojo |
| Nominee | Inspiration - 1943 | Corporal Lynn Bridges |
| Nominee | En Garde! - 1943 | Abby Lu Ashley+Al Ashley |
| Nominee | Light - 1943 | Leslie A. Croutch |
| Nominee | Chanticleer - 1943 | Walt Liebscher |
| Nominee | British Fantasy Society Bulletin - 1943 | uncredited |
| Nominee | Horizons - 1943 | Harry Warner, Jr. |
| Nominee | Fanfare - 1943 | Art Widner+Pete Widner+Ruth Widner |
| Nominee | Cosmic Circle Commentator - 1943 | Don Rogers |
| Nominee | The Madman of Mars - 1943 | Forrest Ackerman |
| Winner | untitled | Forrest J. Ackerman |
| Runner-up | untitled | Wilson 'Bob' Tucker |
| Finalist | untitled | Donald A. Wollheim |
| Finalist | untitled | Morojo |
| Finalist | untitled | Jack Speer |
| Nominee | untitled | Art Widner |
| Nominee | untitled | Harry Warner, Jr. |
| Nominee | untitled | Larry Shaw |
| Nominee | untitled | Lynn Bridges |
| Nominee | untitled | Julius Unger |
| Nominee | untitled | E. Everett Evans |
| Nominee | untitled | Francis Towner Laney |
| Nominee | untitled | Leslie E. Crouch |
| Nominee | untitled | Al Ashley |
| Nominee | untitled | Walter J. Daugherty |
| Nominee | untitled | Don Rogers |
| Nominee | untitled | Douglas Webster |
| Nominee | untitled | Harry Jenkins, Jr. |
| Nominee | untitled | Harry Turner |
| Nominee | untitled | Helen Bradleigh |
| Nominee | untitled | J. Michael Rosenblum |
| Nominee | untitled | Russ Chauvenet |
| Nominee | untitled | William S. Sykora |
| Nominee | untitled | Robert Clyne |
| Winner | Beyond This Horizon | Robert A. Heinlein |
| Runner-up | Second Stage Lensmen | Edward E. Smith |
| Finalist | Darkness and the Light | Olaf Stapledon |
| Finalist | Donovan's Brain | Curt Siodmak |
| Finalist | The Uninvited | Dorothy Macardle |
| Nominee | Islandia | Austin Tappan Wright |
| Nominee | The Screwtape Letters | C. S. Lewis |
| Nominee | Grand Canyon | Vita Sackville-West |
| Nominee | The Sorcerer's Ship | Hannes Bok |
| Nominee | The Land of Unreason | L. Sprague de Camp+Fletcher Pratt |
| Nominee | Rocket to the Morgue | Anthony Boucher |
| Nominee | Superman | George Lowther |
| Winner | Waldo | Anson MacDonald |
| Runner-up | The Unpleasant Profession of Jonathan Hoag | John Riverside |
| Finalist | Nerves | Lester del Rey |
| Finalist | The Compleat Werewolf | Anthony Boucher |
| Finalist | Asylum | A. E. van Vogt |
| Nominee | Hell Is Forever | Alfred Bester |
| Nominee | The Screwtape Letters | C. S. Lewis |
| Nominee | Recruiting Station | A. E. van Vogt |
| Nominee | The Push of a Finger | Alfred Bester |
| Nominee | Barrier | Anthony Boucher |
| Winner | Foundation | Isaac Asimov |
| Runner-up | The Weapon Shop | A. E. van Vogt |
| Finalist | There Shall Be Darkness | C. L. Moore |
| Finalist | The Star Mouse | Fredric Brown |
| Finalist | Bridle and Saddle | Isaac Asimov |
| Nominee | Goldfish Bowl | Anson MacDonald |
| Nominee | The Twonky | Henry Kuttner+C. L. Moore |
| Nominee | The Sorcerer of Rhiannon | Leigh Brackett |
| Nominee | QRM - Interplanetary | George O. Smith |
| Nominee | Runaround | Isaac Asimov |
| Nominee | Medusa | Theodore Sturgeon |
| Nominee | Child of the Sun | Leigh Brackett |
| Winner | The Twonky | Henry Kuttner+C. L. Moore |
| Runner-up | Proof | Hal Clement |
| Finalist | Runaround | Isaac Asimov |
| Finalist | The Sunken Land | Fritz Leiber |
| Finalist | Etaoin Shrdlu | Fredric Brown |
| Nominee | Mimic | Martin Pearson |
| Winner | Bambi | Perce Pearce+Larry Morey+David D. Hand |
| Runner-up | Cat People | DeWitt Bodeen+Jacques Tourneur |
| Finalist | Rudyard Kipling's Jungle Book | Laurence Stallings+Zoltan Korda |
| Finalist | I Married a Witch | Robert Pirosh+Marc Connelly+René Clair |
| Finalist | The Ghost of Frankenstein | W. Scott Darling+Erle C. Kenton |
| Nominee | Invisible Agent | Curt Siodmak+Edwin L. Marin |
| Winner | untitled | John W. Campbell |
| Runner-up | untitled | Donald A. Wollheim |
| Finalist | untitled | Dorothy McIlwraith |
| Finalist | untitled | Raymond A. Palmer |
| Finalist | untitled | Oscar J. Friend |
| Nominee | untitled | Malcolm Reiss |
| Winner | untitled | Virgil Finlay |
| Runner-up | untitled | Hannes Bok |
| Finalist | untitled | Margaret Brundage |
| Finalist | untitled | Edd Cartier |
| Finalist | untitled | Hubert Rogers |
| Nominee | untitled | Harold W. McCauley |
| Winner | Le Zombie - 1942 | Wilson Tucker+E. Everett Evans |
| Runner-up | The Phantagraph - 1942 | Donald A. Wollheim |
| Finalist | Spaceways - 1942 | Harry Warner, Jr. |
| Finalist | Voice of the Imagi-Nation - 1942 | Forrest J Ackerman+Morojo |
| Finalist | Futurian War Digest - 1942 | J. Michael Rosenblum |
| Nominee | Inspiration - 1942 | Lynn Bridges |
| Winner | untitled | Forrest J. Ackerman |
| Runner-up | untitled | Wilson Tucker |
| Finalist | untitled | Donald A. Wollheim |
| Finalist | untitled | Harry Warner, Jr. |
| Finalist | untitled | Jack Speer |
| Nominee | untitled | Art Widner |
| Winner | Slan | A. E. van Vogt |
| Runner-up | Gray Lensman | Edward E. Smith |
| Finalist | The Ill-Made Knight | T. H. White |
| Finalist | The Reign of Wizardry | Jack Williamson |
| Finalist | Kallocain | Karin Boye |
| Nominee | The Incomplete Enchanter | L. Sprague de Camp+Fletcher Pratt |
| Nominee | Final Blackout | L. Ron Hubbard |
| Nominee | Typewriter in the Sky | L. Ron Hubbard |
| Nominee | Twice in Time | Manly Wade Wellman |
| Nominee | Synthetic Men of Mars | Edgar Rice Burroughs |
| Nominee | Captain Future and the Space Emperor | Edmond Hamilton |
| Nominee | A Million Years to Conquer | Henry Kuttner |
| Nominee | The Wonder City of Oz | John R. Neill |
| Nominee | The Man Who Went Back | Warwick Deeping |
| Nominee | The Twenty-Fifth Hour | Herbert Best |
| Winner | "If This Goes On —" | Robert A. Heinlein |
| Runner-up | Magic, Inc. | Robert A. Heinlein |
| Finalist | Coventry | Robert A. Heinlein |
| Finalist | The Mathematics of Magic | L. Sprague de Camp+Fletcher Pratt |
| Finalist | The Roaring Trumpet | L. Sprague de Camp+Fletcher Pratt |
| Nominee | The Wheels of If | L. Sprague de Camp |
| Nominee | Darker Than You Think | Jack Williamson |
| Nominee | By His Bootstraps | Robert A. Heinlein |
| Nominee | Universe | Robert A. Heinlein |
| Nominee | Soldiers of the Black Goat | Marian O'Hearn |
| Nominee | La invención de Morel | Adolfo Bioy Casares |
| Nominee | The Mound | H. P. Lovecraft+Zealia Bishop |
| Nominee | But Without Horns | Norvell W. Page |
| Nominee | The Sun Maker | Jack Williamson |
| Winner | The Roads Must Roll | Robert A. Heinlein |
| Runner-up | Blowups Happen | Robert A. Heinlein |
| Finalist | It | Theodore Sturgeon |
| Finalist | Farewell to the Master | Harry Bates |
| Finalist | Vault of the Beast | A. E. van Vogt |
| Nominee | Darker Than You Think | Jack Williamson |
| Nominee | Fruit of Knowledge | C. L. Moore |
| Nominee | Into the Darkness | Ross Rocklynne |
| Nominee | The Voyage That Lasted 600 Years | Don Wilcox |
| Nominee | Half-Breed | Isaac Asimov |
| Nominee | John Carter of Mars | Edgar Rice Burroughs |
| Nominee | The Hardwood Pile | L. Sprague de Camp |
| Nominee | All Is Illusion | Henry Kuttner+C. L. Moore |
| Nominee | Cargo | Theodore Sturgeon |
| Nominee | The Warrior Race | L. Sprague de Camp |
| Nominee | Voyage to Nowhere | Alfred Bester |
| Winner | Robbie | Isaac Asimov |
| Runner-up | Requiem | Robert A. Heinlein |
| Finalist | Martian Quest | Leigh Brackett |
| Finalist | The Stellar Legion | Leigh Brackett |
| Finalist | Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius | Jorge Luís Borges |
| Nominee | Let There Be Light | Robert A. Heinlein |
| Nominee | Quietus | Ross Rocklynne |
| Nominee | The Bleak Shore | Fritz Leiber |
| Nominee | Hindsight | Jack Williamson |
| Nominee | Song in a Minor Key | C. L. Moore |
| Nominee | The Automatic Pistol | Fritz Leiber |
| Nominee | Clerical Error | Clifford D. Simak |
| Nominee | Dark Mission | Lester del Rey |
| Nominee | Nightfall | Isaac Asimov |
| Nominee | Homo Sol | Isaac Asimov |
| Nominee | The Tapestry Gate | Leigh Brackett |
| Winner | Batman #1 | |
| Runner-up | Flash Gordon: "The Ice Kingdom of Mongo" | Alex Raymond+Don Moore |
| Finalist | The Origin of the Spirit | Will Eisner |
| Finalist | Captain Marvel: "Introducing Captain Marvel" | Bill Parker+C. C. Beck |
| Finalist | The Spectre: "The Spectre"/"The Spectre Strikes!" | Jerry Siegel+Bernard Baily |
| Nominee | Captain America Comics #1 | Joe Simon+Jack Kirby |
| Nominee | Horton Hatches the Egg | Dr. Seuss |
| Nominee | Flash Comics #1 | Gardner Fox+Sheldon Moldoff+Harry Lamper |
| Nominee | Prince Valiant | Hal Foster |
| Nominee | Flash Gordon |
| Winner | Fantasia | Joe Grant+Dick Huemer+Samuel Armstrong |
| Runner-up | The Thief of Bagdad | Lajos Bíró+Miles Malleson+Michael Powell+Ludwig Berger+Tim Whelan |
| Finalist | Flash Gordon Conquers the Universe | George H. Plympton+Basil Dickey+Barry Shipman+Ford Beebe+Ray Taylor |
| Finalist | One Million B.C | Mickell Novack+George Baker+Joseph Frickert+Hal Roach+Hal Roach, Jr. |
| Finalist | Dr. Cyclops | Tom Kilpatrick+Ernest B. Schoedsack |
| Nominee | The Invisible Man Return | Joe May+Kurt Siodmak+Lester Cole |
| Nominee | Son of Ingagi | Spencer Williams+Richard C. Kahn |
| Nominee | The Invisible Woman | Kurt Siodmak+Joe May+A. Edward Sutherland |
| Nominee | Mysterious Doctor Satan | John English+William Witney |
| Nominee | Black Friday | Curt Siodmak |
| Nominee | The Great Dictator | Charlie Chaplin |
| Nominee | The Shadow | James W. Horne |
| Winner | Pinocchio | Ted Sears+Ben Sharpsteen+Hamilton Luske |
| Runner-up | Merrie Melodies: "A Wild Hare" | Rich Hogan+Tex Avery |
| Finalist | Looney Tunes: "You Ought to Be in Pictures" | Jack Miller+Friz Freleng |
| Finalist | The Adventures of Superman: "The Baby from Krypton" | George Ludlam+Frank Chase |
| Finalist | The Invisible Man Returns | Joe May+Kurt Siodmak+Lester Cole |
| Nominee | Puss Gets the Boot | William Hanna+Joseph Barbera+Rudolf Ising |
| Nominee | The Milky Way | Rudolf Ising |
| Nominee | One Million B.C. | Hal Roach+Hal Roach, Jr. |
| Nominee | The Invisible Woman | Curt Siodmak+Joe May+A. Edward Sutherland |
| Nominee | The Sorcerer's Apprentice | Walt Disney |
| Nominee | Buck Rogers | |
| Nominee | Night on Bald Mountain | Wilfred Jackson |
| Nominee | Scrappy Man of Tin | |
| Nominee | Son of Ingagi | |
| Nominee | Weltraumschiff 1 Startet |
| Winner | untitled | John W. Campbell |
| Runner-up | untitled | Frederik Pohl |
| Finalist | untitled | Dorothy McIlwraith |
| Finalist | untitled | Raymond A. Palmer |
| Finalist | untitled | Mort Weisinger |
| Nominee | untitled | Malcolm Reiss |
| Nominee | untitled | Farnsworth Wright |
| Nominee | untitled | Mary Gnaedinger |
| Nominee | untitled | Charles D. Hornig |
| Nominee | untitled | Martin Goodman |
| Winner | untitled | Virgil Finlay |
| Runner-up | untitled | Hannes Bok |
| Finalist | untitled | Margaret Brundage |
| Finalist | untitled | Frank R. Paul |
| Finalist | untitled | Edd Cartier |
| Nominee | untitled | Hubert Rogers |
| Nominee | untitled | Robert Fuqua |
| Nominee | untitled | Howard V. Brown |
| Nominee | untitled | Earle Bergey |
| Nominee | untitled | J. Allen St. John |
| Nominee | untitled | J. W. Scott |
| Nominee | untitled | Alex Schomburg |
| Nominee | untitled | Charles Schneeman |
| Winner | Futuria Fantasia - 1940 | Ray Bradbury |
| Runner-up | Le Zombie - 1940 | Bob Tucker |
| Finalist | Spaceways - 1940 | Harry Warner, Jr. |
| Finalist | Voice of the Imagi-Nation - 1940 | Forrest J. Ackerman+Morojo |
| Finalist | Novacious - 1940 | Forrest J. Ackerman+Morojo |
| Nominee | The Phantagraph | Donald A. Wollheim |
| Nominee | Detours | Russ Chauvenet |
| Nominee | Snide | Damon Knight |
| Nominee | Futurian War Digest | J. Michael Rosenblum |
| Nominee | Spaceship | |
| Nominee | YHOS | Art Widner |
| Winner | untitled | Ray Bradbury |
| Runner-up | untitled | Forrest J Ackerman |
| Finalist | untitled | Bob Tucker |
| Finalist | untitled | H. P. Lovecraft |
| Finalist | untitled | Harry Warner |
| Nominee | untitled | Art Widner |
| Winner | The Sword in the Stone | T. H. White |
| Runner-up | Out of the Silent Planet | C. S. Lewis |
| Finalist | Galactic Patrol | Edward E. Smith |
| Finalist | The Legion of Time | Jack Williamson |
| Finalist | Carson of Venus | Edgar Rice Burroughs |
| Nominee | The Silver Princess in Oz | Ruth Plumly Thompson |
| Nominee | Tarzan and the Forbidden City | Edgar Rice Burroughs |
| Nominee | Synthetic Men of Mars | Edgar Rice Burroughs |
| Nominee | The Drums of Fu Manchu | Sax Rohmer |
| Nominee | At Midnight on the 31st of March | Josephine Young Case |
| Nominee | The Doomsday Men | J. B. Priestley |
| Nominee | Towers in the Mist | Elizabeth Goudge |
| Winner | Who Goes There? | John W. Campbell, Jr. |
| Runner-up | The Time Trap | Henry Kuttner |
| Finalist | Sleepers of Mars | John Wyndham |
| Finalist | A Matter of Form | H. L. Gold |
| Finalist | Anthem | Ayn Rand |
| Nominee | Tarzan the Magnificent | Edgar Rice Burroughs |
| Nominee | Black Vulmea's Vengeance | Robert E. Howard |
| Nominee | Dreadful Sleep | Jack Williamson |
| Nominee | The Black Drama | Manly Wade Wellman |
| Nominee | The Hairy Ones Shall Dance | Manly Wade Wellman |
| Winner | Rule 18 | Clifford D. Simak |
| Runner-up | Pigeons from Hell | Robert E. Howard |
| Finalist | Werewoman | C. L. Moore |
| Finalist | Hollywood on the Moon | Henry Kuttner |
| Finalist | Dead Knowledge | John W. Campbell, Jr. |
| Nominee | Secret of the Observatory | Robert Bloch |
| Nominee | Seeds of the Dusk | Raymond Z. Gallun |
| Nominee | Reunion on Ganymede | Clifford D. Simak |
| Nominee | The Men and the Mirror | Ross Rocklynne |
| Nominee | Beyond the Screen | John Beynon |
| Nominee | The World's Eighth Wonder | Eric Frank Russell |
| Nominee | The Dead Spot | Jack Williamson |
| Winner | How We Went to Mars | Arthur C. Clarke |
| Runner-up | Helen O'Loy | Lester del Rey |
| Finalist | Hollerbochen's Dilemma | Ray Bradbury |
| Finalist | Hyperpelosity | L. Sprague de Camp |
| Finalist | The Faithful | Lester del Rey |
| Nominee | An Experiment of the Dead | Helen Simpson (1897-1940) |
| Nominee | The Merman | L. Sprague de Camp |
| Nominee | Robots Return | Robert Moore Williams |
| Nominee | The Book | H. P. Lovecraft |
| Nominee | The Brain Pirates | John W. Campbell |
| Nominee | Between Two Worlds | Mary Lutyens |
| Nominee | With and Without Buttons | Mary Butts |
| Nominee | Janice | Shirley Jackson |
| Winner | The War of the Worlds by H. G. Wells | Howard Koch+Anne Froelick |
| Runner-up | R. U. R. | Karel Čapek |
| Finalist | Around the World in Eighty Days by Jules Verne | Orson Welles |
| Finalist | A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens | Orson Welles |
| Finalist | Dracula by Bram Stoker | Orson Welles+John Houseman |
| Nominee | Brave Little Tailor | Walt Disney |
| Nominee | Porky in Wackyland | Robert Clampett |
| Nominee | Mother Goose Goes to Hollywood | Dick Richard+Wilfred Jackson |
| Nominee | The Man Who Was Thursday | Orson Welles |
| Winner | untitled | John W. Campbell, Jr. |
| Runner-up | untitled | Farnsworth Wright |
| Finalist | untitled | Raymond A. Palmer |
| Finalist | untitled | Mort Weisinger |
| Finalist | untitled | Walter H. Gillings |
| Nominee | untitled | T. O'Conor Sloane |
| Winner | untitled | Virgil Finlay |
| Runner-up | untitled | Margaret Brundage |
| Finalist | untitled | Frank R. Paul |
| Finalist | untitled | Alex Schomburg |
| Finalist | untitled | H. W. Wesso |
| Nominee | untitled | Howard V. Brown |
| Nominee | untitled | Charles Schneeman |
| Nominee | untitled | Norman Saunders |
| Nominee | untitled | Leo Morey |
| Winner | Imagination! - 1938 | Forrest J. Ackerman |
| Runner-up | Novae Terrae | Maurice K. Hanson |
| Finalist | Tomorrow | Douglas W. F. Mayer |
| Finalist | Fantascience Digest | Robert A. Madle |
| Finalist | Fantasy News | James V. Taurasi |
| Nominee | Science Fiction Newsletter |
| Winner | untitled | Ray Bradbury |
| Runner-up | untitled | Forrest J. Ackerman |
| Finalist | untitled | Wilson Tucker |
| Finalist | untitled | Donald A. Wollheim |
| Finalist | untitled | Harry Warner, Jr. |
| Nominee | untitled | Sam Moskowitz |
| Nominee | untitled | William F. Temple |
| Nominee | untitled | Robert A. Madle |
| Winner | Fahrenheit 451 | Ray Bradbury |
| Runner-up | Childhood's End | Arthur C. Clarke |
| Finalist | Mission of Gravity | Hal Clement |
| Finalist | The Caves of Steel | Isaac Asimov |
| Finalist | More Than Human | Theodore Sturgeon |
| Winner | A Case of Conscience | James Blish |
| Runner-up | Three Hearts and Three Lions | Poul Anderson |
| Finalist | . . . And My Fear Is Great . . . | Theodore Sturgeon |
| Finalist | Un-Man | Poul Anderson |
| Finalist | The Rose | Charles L. Harness |
| Nominee | Daughters of Earth | Judith Merril |
| Winner | Earthman, Come Home | James Blish |
| Runner-up | Second Variety | Philip K. Dick |
| Finalist | The Adventure of the Misplaced Hound | Poul Anderson+Gordon R. Dickson |
| Finalist | Sam Hall | Poul Anderson |
| Finalist | The Wall Around the World | Theodore R. Cogswell |
| Winner | The Nine Billion Names of God | Arthur C. Clarke |
| Runner-up | It's a Good Life | Jerome Bixby |
| Finalist | Star Light, Star Bright | Alfred Bester |
| Finalist | A Saucer of Loneliness | Theodore Sturgeon |
| Finalist | Seventh Victim | Robert Sheckley |
| Winner | Conquest of the Moon | Wernher von Braun+Willy Ley+Fred L. Whipple |
| Runner-up | Science-Fiction Handbook | L. Sprague de Camp |
| Finalist | Modern Science Fiction: Its Meaning and Its Future | Reginald Bretnor |
| Nominee | untitled |
| Winner | The War of the Worlds | Barré Lyndon |
| Runner-up | Duck Dodgers in the 24½th Century | Michael Maltese |
| Finalist | It Came from Outer Space | Harry Essex+Ray Bradbury |
| Finalist | The Beast from 20,000 Fathoms | Fred Freiberger+Eugène Lourié+Louis Morheim+Robert Smith |
| Finalist | Invaders from Mars | Richard Blake+John Tucker Battle |
| Winner | untitled | John W. Campbell, Jr. |
| Runner-up | untitled | Frederik Pohl |
| Finalist | untitled | Donald A. Wollheim |
| Finalist | untitled | Anthony Boucher |
| Finalist | untitled | H. L. Gold |
| Winner | untitled | Chesley Bonestell |
| Runner-up | untitled | Frank Kelly Freas |
| Finalist | untitled | Virgil Finlay |
| Finalist | untitled | Ed Emshwiller |
| Finalist | untitled | Richard Powers |
| Nominee | untitled |
| Winner | Slant | Walt Willis |
| Runner-up | Science Fiction Newsletter | Wilson Tucker |
| Finalist | Quandry | Lee Hoffman |
| Finalist | Hyphen | Chuck Harris+Walt Willis |
| Finalist | Sky Hook | Redd Boggs |
| Winner | untitled | Wilson Tucker |
| Runner-up | untitled | Walt Willis |
| Finalist | untitled | James White |
| Finalist | untitled | Lee Hoffman |
| Finalist | untitled | Redd Boggs |
| Nominee | untitled |
| Winner | Farmer in the Sky | Robert A. Heinlein |
| Runner-up | Pebble in the Sky | Isaac Asimov |
| Finalist | The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe | C. S. Lewis |
| Finalist | First Lensman | Edward E. Smith |
| Finalist | The Dying Earth | Jack Vance |
| Nominee | Needle^From Outer Space | Hal Clement |
| Nominee | Gormenghast | Mervyn Peake |
| Nominee | The Voyage of the Space Beagle | A. E. van Vogt |
| Winner | The Man Who Sold the Moon | Robert A. Heinlein |
| Runner-up | The Dreaming Jewels^Synthetic Man | Theodore Sturgeon |
| Finalist | . . . And Now You Don't | Isaac Asimov |
| Finalist | The Last Enemy | H. Beam Piper |
| Finalist | To the Stars | L. Ron Hubbard |
| Winner | The Little Black Bag | C. M. Kornbluth |
| Runner-up | Scanners Live in Vain | Cordwainer Smith |
| Finalist | The Helping Hand | Poul Anderson |
| Finalist | Okie | James Blish |
| Finalist | Dear Devil | Eric Frank Russell |
| Nominee | Bindlestiff | James Blish |
| Nominee | The Second Night of Summer | James H. Schmitz |
| Winner | To Serve Man | Damon Knight |
| Runner-up | Coming Attraction | Fritz Leiber |
| Finalist | Born of Man and Woman | Richard Matheson |
| Finalist | A Subway Named Mobius | A. J. Deutsch |
| Finalist | The Gnurrs Come from the Voodvork Out | Reginald Bretnor |
| Nominee | A Walk in the Dark | Arthur C. Clarke |
| Nominee | The Silly Season | C. M. Kornbluth |
| Nominee | Insufficient Nominations - Not on ballot | (********) |
| Winner | Destination Moon | Robert A. Heinlein+Alfort Van Ronkel+James O'Hanlon |
| Runner-up | Harvey | Mary Chase+Oscar Brodney |
| Finalist | Cinderella | Ken Anderson+Homer Brightman |
| Finalist | Rabbit of Seville | Chuck Jones+Michael Maltese |
| Finalist | Rocketship X-M | Kurt Neumann+Dalton Trumbo |
| Nominee | Rashomon | Shinobu Hashimoto |
| Winner | Astounding Science Fiction | John W. Campbell, Jr. |
| Runner-up | untitled | Anthony Boucher |
| Finalist | untitled | H. L. Gold |
| Finalist | untitled | Groff Conklin |
| Finalist | untitled | J. Francis McComas |
| Winner | untitled | Frank Kelly Freas^Kelly Freas |
| Runner-up | untitled | Chesley Bonestell |
| Finalist | untitled | Virgil Finlay |
| Finalist | untitled | Edd Cartier |
| Finalist | untitled | Hannes Bok |
| Nominee | untitled | Ed Emshwiller |
| Nominee | untitled |
| Winner | Science Fiction Newsletter | Wilson Tucker^Bob Tucker |
| Runner-up | Slant | Walt Willis |
| Finalist | Quandry | Lee Hoffman |
| Finalist | Skyhook | Redd Boggs |
| Finalist | Spacewarp | Art Rapp |
| Nominee | The Fanscient | Donald B. Day |
| Winner | untitled | Robert Silverberg |
| Runner-up | untitled | Wilson Tucker^Bob Tucker |
| Finalist | untitled | James White |
| Finalist | untitled | Walt Willis |
| Finalist | untitled | Lee Hoffman |
| Nominee | untitled | Harlan Ellison |
| Winner | untitled | Jack Gaughan |
| Runner-up | untitled | William Rotsler^Bill Rotsler |
| Finalist | untitled | James White |
| Finalist | untitled | Lee Hoffman |
| Finalist | untitled | Ray Nelson |
| Nominee | untitled | David A. Kyle |
| Nominee | untitled | Bjo Trimble |
| Winner | The Mule | Isaac Asimov |
| Runner-up | The World of Null-A | A. E. van Vogt |
| Finalist | That Hideous Strength^The Tortured Planet (1958 US) | C. S. Lewis |
| Finalist | Destiny Times Three | Fritz Leiber |
| Finalist | Red Sun of Danger^Danger Planet | Edmond Hamilton^Brett Sterling |
| Winner | Animal Farm | George Orwell |
| Runner-up | The Dead Hand | Isaac Asimov |
| Finalist | Giant Killer | A. Bertram Chandler |
| Finalist | "I Remember Lemuria!" | Richard S. Shaver |
| Winner | First Contact | Murray Leinster |
| Runner-up | Pi in the Sky | Fredric Brown |
| Finalist | Into Thy Hands | Lester del Rey |
| Finalist | The Mixed Men^Mission to the Stars | A. E. van Vogt |
| Finalist | The Piper's Son | (Henry Kuttner+C. L. Moore)^Lewis Padgett |
| Nominee | Things Pass By | Murray Leinster |
| Nominee | Beggars in Velvet | (Henry Kuttner+C. L. Moore)^Lewis Padgett |
| Nominee | The Lion and the Unicorn | (Henry Kuttner+C. L. Moore)^Lewis Padgett |
| Nominee | Three Blind Mice | (Henry Kuttner+C. L. Moore)^Lewis Padgett |
| Nominee | Pandora's Millions | George O. Smith |
| Nominee | Special Delivery | George O. Smith |
| Winner | Uncommon Sense | Hal Clement |
| Runner-up | The Ethical Equations | Murray Leinster |
| Finalist | The Waveries | Fredric Brown |
| Finalist | What You Need | (Henry Kuttner+C. L. Moore)^Lewis Padgett |
| Finalist | Correspondence Course | Raymond F. Jones |
| Nominee | Blind Alley | Isaac Asimov |
| Nominee | Paradoxical Escape | Isaac Asimov |
| Nominee | Lefty Feep Gets Henpecked | Robert Bloch |
| Nominee | De Profundis | Murray Leinster |
| Nominee | The Power | Murray Leinster |
| Nominee | Line to Tomorrow | (Henry Kuttner+C. L. Moore)^Lewis Padgett |
| Nominee | The World-Thinker | Jack Vance |
| Winner | The Picture of Dorian Gray | Albert Lewin+Oscar Wilde |
| Runner-up | Blithe Spirit | Noël Coward |
| Finalist | The Body Snatcher | Val Lewton+Philip MacDonald+Robert Louis Stevenson |
| Finalist | House of Dracula | Edward T. Lowe, Jr. |
| Finalist | The Horn Blows at Midnight | Sam Hellman+James V. Kern |
| Nominee | Dead of Night | John Baines+E. F. Benson+T. E. B. Clarke+Angus MacPhail+H. G. Wells |
| Nominee | The Road to Utopia | Melvin Frank+Norman Panama |
| Nominee | Wonder Man | Don Hardman+Jack Jevne+Eddie Moran+Philip Rapp+Melville Shavelson+Arthur Sheekman |
| Nominee | Isle of the Dead | Josef Mischel+Ardel Wray |
| Nominee | House of Frankenstein | Curt Siodmak+Edward T. Lowe, Jr. |
| Winner | Astounding Science Fiction | John W. Campbell, Jr. |
| Runner-up | untitled | Donald A. Wollheim |
| Finalist | Amazing | Raymond A. Palmer |
| Finalist | Thrilling Wonder Stories / Startling Stories | Sam Merwin, Jr. |
| Winner | untitled | Virgil Finlay |
| Runner-up | untitled | Hannes Bok |
| Finalist | untitled | Frank R. Paul |
| Finalist | untitled | Edd Cartier |
| Finalist | untitled | Earle K. Bergey |
| Nominee | untitled | Chesley Bonestell |
| Nominee | untitled | Ed Emshwiller |
| Nominee | untitled | Paul Orban |
| Nominee | untitled | Alex Schomburg |
| Nominee | untitled | William Timmins |
| Winner | Voice of the Imagi-Nation | Forrest J Ackerman |
| Runner-up | Chanticleer | Walt Liebscher |
| Finalist | Shangri L'Affaires | Charles E. Burbee+Gerald Hewitt |
| Finalist | The Acolyte | Francis Towner Laney+Russell |
| Finalist | Fantasy Commentator | A. Langley Searles |
| Nominee | Le Zombie | Unknown-Mags |
| Nominee | YHOS | Unknown-Mags |
| Winner | untitled | Forrest J Ackerman |
| Runner-up | untitled | Wilson Tucker |
| Finalist | untitled | Charles E. Burbee |
| Finalist | untitled | Art Widner |
| Finalist | untitled | Francis Towner Laney |
| Nominee | untitled | Robert Bloch |
| Nominee | untitled | Joe Kennedy |
| Nominee | untitled | Jack Speer |
| Winner | untitled | William Rotsler |
| Runner-up | untitled | Alva Rogers |
| Finalist | untitled | Joe Gibson |
| Finalist | untitled | Lou Goldstone, Jr. |
| Finalist | untitled | Jack Wiedenbeck |