Only speculative contents are indexed here. The remaining stories are:
- 1 • The General Court and Jane Andrews' Firkin of Butter • short story by Seba Smith [Graham's Magazine, October 1847]
- 13 • The Red Brother and the White Brother • Professor Ingraham [New England Magazine, July 1911]
- 49 • The Amorous Adventures of Mister John Beedle • short story by William L. McClintock [John Beedle's Sleigh Ride, Courtship and Marriage (1841)]
- 67 • In the Gray Goth • short story by Elizabeth Stuart Phelps Ward [Men, Women, and Ghosts (1869)]
- 87 • The Downfall of Master Lurvey • novelette by C. A. Stephens [A Great Year of Our Lives at the Old Squire's (1912)]
- 117 • Fred, and Maria, and Me • novelette by E. P. Prentiss [Hours at Home, in 2 parts, May and June 1865]
- 145 • Home • short story by Lincoln Colcord [??]
- 163 • On a Melon Schooner • short story by Barnet Phillips [Harper's Magazine, October 1877]
185 • Delia Grimwet • short story by Arlo Bates [Lippincott's Magazine, September 1883]
- 227 • The Love Letters of Smith • short story by H. C. Bunner [Puck, July 23, 1890]
- 237 • The Fore-Room Rug • short story by Kate Douglas Wiggin [The Village Watchtower (1895)]
- 249 • A Return to Constancy • short story by Mary Ellen Chase [Harper's Magazine, November 1918]
- 281 • A Truth Party • short story by Harriet A. Nash [Designer, February 1906]
- 289 • Old Tantrybogus • short story by Ben Ames Williams [Saturday Evening Post, March 6, 1920]
- 311 • The Triumph of Hiram Perkins • short story by George A. Cleveland [Maine in Verse and Story (1915)]
- 321 • Goblin Peaches • short story by Alfred Noyes [Walking Shadows (1918)]
