In the November 1832 edition Atkinson's Casket (no.11), which gives the source as the NY Constellation.
| Date | Publication | Publisher | Type | Page | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 1971 |
|
Witches, Wraiths & Warlocks: Supernatural Tales of the American Renaissance | Fawcett Premier | Anthology | 53 |
| March 1973 |
|
Witches, Wraiths & Warlocks: Supernatural Tales of the American Renaissance | Fawcett Premier | Anthology | 53 |
| October 1988 |
|
Witches, Wraiths and Warlocks: Supernatural Tales of the American Renaissance | Fawcett Premier / Ballantine | Anthology | 64 |