| Date | Publication | Publisher | Type | Page | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| August 1949 |
|
Astounding Science Fiction, August 1949 | Street & Smith Publications, Inc. | MAGAZINE | 147 |
| March 1978 |
|
The Best of Astounding | Baronet Publishing Co. | Anthology | 15 |
| June 1978 |
|
The Best of Astounding | Baronet Publishing Co. | Anthology | 15 |
| January 1979 |
|
The Best of Astounding | Ace Books | Anthology | 15 |
| January 1990 |
|
Analog Science Fiction and Fact, January 1990 | Davis Publications | MAGAZINE | 295 |